My Simple Marketing Fix Worth $5 Million

1 0 4 minutes read

How I went from a $2.6 million loss to a $5 million gain in 2 years

Running a business is difficult at the best times, and adding in today’s persistent inflation, cautious consumer spending, and labor shortages certainly doesn’t help.

The latest NFIB Small Business Optimism Survey found that inflation remains the top concern for small business owners. Lower consumer spending is also fueling the pressure.

I’ve reacted to these pressures before and made economically driven decisions that were disastrous, costing me $2.6 million.

While times are tough right now, I don’t

While times are tough right now, I don’t want you to make the same mistake I did the last time the economy took a turn for the worse. Here’s the mistake that led to a $2.6 million loss—and how I turned it into a $5 million gain the following year.

The daily digest for entrepreneurs and business leaders

An Inc.com Featured Presentation

1. Find your best customers and market to more people like them.

In 2008, mortgage brokers and the real estate industry made up the largest portion of our clients, at 46 percent of revenue. Then the housing bubble burst and those clients vanished overnight. Looking for solutions, I talked to my advisors and they suggested cutting back on our postcard marketing, which made up a huge percentage of our weekly expenses.

I went against my better judgment and did it. That mistake made our situation even worse. The following year, 2009, our revenue declined $2.6 million.

Our lead flow slowed, our revenue dropped even

Our lead flow slowed, our revenue dropped even further, and the savings from cutting marketing were dwarfed by the business we stopped generating. The lesson forever changed the way I think about marketing.

The answer is to spend smarter.

To correct the problem, I analyzed where our sales were coming from. We discovered that a ton of different industries that we never actively marketed to were buying from us.

We realized that these industries were finding us online, so we immediately started mailing to them. Our revenue bounced back rapidly, adding just over $5 million to our total revenue, and 2010 was another highest-earning year for us.

Instead of giving into pressure to cut back

So instead of giving into pressure to cut back or kill your marketing, invest in the leads and customers that will bring in the most profit and long-term business. Every business has customers that are more profitable than others. They buy more often, stay longer, and refer new business.

Find those customers. Then ask yourself how you can reach more people just like them.

The better you define your ideal customer, the less money you waste trying to convince everyone else.

2. Track everything and invest in what actually makes you money.

Identifying your key customers is essential, but you

Identifying your key customers is essential, but you also have to carefully select which marketing channels produce the best results.

Revenue and return on investment matter more than response rate.

If you aren’t tracking where your leads come from—and what those leads are worth—you can’t make intelligent marketing decisions. So start tracking and then invest where it matters.

We did this recently and analyzed over 117,000 of our own leads and sales from 2025 and discovered direct mail leads generated 978 percent more revenue per lead than digital leads. And this number has been steadily improving. Our revenue per direct mail lead has grown 78 percent since 2023, while our revenue per digital lead has actually shrunk 0.95 percent over the same period.

This is the kind of data we use

This is the kind of data we use to inform our marketing decisions. Based on those test results, we mail over 260,000 postcards every week just to advertise ourselves.

3. Keep marketing, even when it’s uncomfortable.

When sales slow down, marketing often feels like the easiest expense to cut. That’s exactly why it’s usually the worst one. Marketing is what fills tomorrow’s pipeline.

When you stop marketing, you lose today’s leads and create a gap in future revenue that can take months to recover.

After restoring our marketing budget following the 2008

After restoring our marketing budget following the 2008 recession, our lead flow recovered, and so did our business. I promised myself I’d never make that mistake again.

I kept that promise to myself in 2020 when the pandemic started the business shutdowns. Our revenue dropped instantly just like everyone else’s. But this time I didn’t stop my marketing. I held strong and didn’t lower my budget one penny.

This paid off because when everyone else was cutting their marketing budgets, we pushed through. As a result, our leads increased 9.24 percent in the six months following. We ended 2021 up 30 percent in annual revenue.

All of this doesn’t mean you should ignore

All of this doesn’t mean you should ignore your numbers or spend recklessly. It means you should become more disciplined, more targeted, and more accountable for every marketing dollar.

The businesses that continue showing up while competitors go quiet often emerge from difficult economies with greater market share, stronger customer relationships, and healthier pipelines.

Every generation of entrepreneurs faces its own version of economic uncertainty. The businesses that survive are the ones that understand their customers, track what works, and have the discipline to keep marketing when everyone else is pulling back.